Graph theory and algorithms

Lossy Distance-Shell Tomography on Paths: Recovery from Mean and Covariance

ORCID

Preprintv2.0.0

Abstract

Distance-shell sensors report how many targets lie at each hop, without identifying them or separating branches. We show that independent relay failures can make these aggregates more informative. Under nearest-surviving-ancestor bypass, for every known survival probability 0 < p < 1, the mean and covariance of an interior path sensor’s report determine the two integer-valued leg populations up to exchange. Means alone retain exactly the noiseless shell information on every rooted tree. Recovery needs only the covariance diagonal and one adaptively selected column. For legs of length n and counts at most h, a variance-sensitive rounding estimator has an explicit exponential bound at fixed p. At the designed probability p = 2n/(2n + 1), two independent batches give O(h⁴n log(1/δ)) rounds with O(n) scalar accumulators. A binary two-point lower bound proves the matching minimax order Θ_h(n log(1/δ)) for each fixed h and 0 < δ ≤ 1/4.

For nonempty populations with 0 < p < 1, the full law of the total reported count determines an unknown survival probability and the multiset of positive vertex counts. For nonempty binary populations, the mean and covariance already calibrate the survival probability; an explicit counterexample shows why this need not hold for general integer counts. On a spider with 2^k legs, parity populations agree in all joint moments through order k but differ at order k + 1. Endpoint reports connect the model to deletion-channel trace reconstruction, giving imported super-polynomial lower and quasi-polynomial upper bounds at fixed p. Joint landing formulas and a recursive generating function describe how shared ancestry enters the law on general trees. We conjecture that this law identifies the labelled occupied core, with exact finite evidence for every 0 < p < 1. Selected endpoint and two-leg results, together with variance, deterministic rounding and testing components of the sample analysis, are formalized in Lean 4; the full probability guarantee remains a written proof.

Contribution

Recovers the two sides of a path from the mean and covariance of anonymous reports under independent relay failures, using the covariance diagonal and one adaptive column.

Formalization scope

formalized with stated exclusions

What Lean checks

Ten selected Lean statements cover exact two-leg recovery for natural-valued populations under independent relay deletion and nearest-surviving-ancestor bypass, for every known real survival probability 0 < p < 1. The mean and covariance identify the legs up to global exchange; the covariance diagonal and one adaptive column suffice. The selection also proves equality of report laws up to exchange, mean/fold equivalence on paths, endpoint trace and degenerate-probability semantics, actual-model variance and centered-product bounds, conditional deterministic fold and difference reconstruction, and a randomized-testing lower bound with coefficient n/2 for every path length n ≥ 2 at the designed survival probability p = 2n/(2n + 1). Empty and zero populations are allowed, and compared legs have a common finite length.

What it does not check

The full concentration argument, simultaneous recovery probability, sample-splitting independence and complete minimax theorem remain written proofs. Deterministic reconstruction assumes explicit empirical-accuracy and rounding hypotheses; difference recovery also assumes correct deepest-index and magnitude identification. The selected all-length testing bound has coefficient n/2, not the paper’s sharper n. General-tree formulas, unknown-rate calibration, the spider moment obstruction, imported trace-reconstruction complexity and simulation transfer, optimal-rate calculus, the tree conjecture and a separate cross-length padding theorem are outside the selected formal scope. Endpoint trace reconstruction requires the surviving horizon.

This scope is reconciled with the hosted manuscript and pinned project README. The mathematical statements and assumptions in the source determine what the formalization establishes; manuscript revisions may clarify the interpretation of the same proof artifact.

Toolchain
leanprover/lean4:v4.35.0-rc2
Reproduce the formalization
git clone https://github.com/lennrt/palomar-formalizations.git
cd palomar-formalizations
git checkout 9a61a84e3a2e1494bc08b8eaf714c42f3f918325
cd zenodo-23304384/palomar
lake exe cache get
lake build

See the project README for the complete setup, dependencies, and selected declarations.

Citation & version

Lennart Rudolph. (2026). Lossy Distance-Shell Tomography on Paths: Recovery from Mean and Covariance. v2.0.0. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23304384.

View and copy BibTeX
Download .bib

Hosted manuscript
v2.0.0 ·
All versions DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23252713

The repository references 10.5281/zenodo.23252713. The local PDF and citation here describe v2.0.0, identified by its version DOI above.

Version history

  • v1.0.0 · · available from Zenodo
  • v2.0.0 · · hosted here
Manuscript file integrity

SHA-256 of this exact hosted PDF:

1334c6f24f4aae05ed9ca1f5509e7313121fe91611bad9f61659a9cc4ef7636a